What Is The Difference Between a Mixed Use Architect and a Private Residential Architect?

We can all agree that behind every building is a unique design process tailored to its purpose. At Andrew Wallace Architects, we bring together expertise from both residential and mixed-use architecture, providing outstanding service in both fields, as our team is equipped to handle the specific challenges each type of project presents. In this article, we explore the key differences between a mixed-use architect and a private residential architect. So, what is the difference between a mixed-use architect and a private residential architect?

A mixed-use architect specialises in designing buildings that combine multiple functions such as residential living, retail spaces and offices within a single structure, usually for a commercial developer (of all scales). Private residential architects, on the other hand, focus solely on designing individual homes for private clients and tend to focus on the residential aspects of a building without integrating any commercial elements. 

Read on to learn more about the key differences between these two types of architect.  

Key Differences 

Take a look at the main differences between a mixed-use architect and a private residential architect: 

General Requirements

Mixed-Use Architect: All mixed-use buildings will entail carefully thought out construction layouts containing all types of areas, from commercial spaces such as retail outlets, gyms or offices, to residential apartments with car parking and access to community lobbies within them. With this, every space is able to function separately and independently within itself, but in an integrated and coherent way. 

Architects dealing with mixed-use developments have to take into consideration a full array of specific issues, such as sound insulation and fire compartmentalisation between commercial and residential areas, efficient waste management systems for multiple uses, and separate access points for different types of users. 

They must also balance the needs of tenants, business owners, and customers, ensuring that the building operates seamlessly for all parties, like in the project Albion Works. These projects also have to comply with strict building and planning regulations adding to the challenge. 

Mixed-use architects also have to conceptualise and design for possible future changes in usage.  It also helps if the structure is able to accommodate new needs. In the design stage, it has to take into consideration the efficient use of HVAC systems, shared amenities, and parking to ensure the functional cohesion for both user and resident.

[Learn more about Mixed-Use architecture]

Private Residential Architect: On the other hand, private residential architecture is focused on building homes to answer the particular needs of a single person or a family. Such designs focus on multifunctional spaces, detailed room layouts, lighting, storage, and relationships between interior and exterior areas. Residential architects work closely with private clients to understand their lifestyle, preferences, design requirements and aspirations, translating them into designs that reflect their personality. In short, designing for the way they would like to live. 

Every decision (from the positioning of windows and doors to the choice of materials) is done with the comfort and well-being of the occupants in mind, like in the House 141. 

Residential projects also allow architects to focus on intimate details, such as custom cabinetry, personalized colour schemes, and bespoke fixtures. They often incorporate eco-friendly features, such as photovoltaic panels, air-source heat pumps or electric car charging points, ensuring the home is energy-efficient, green and future-proof. Moreover, residential architects overcome issues regarding the maximisation of small spaces, integrating smart home technology, and designing the structure so that it complements its environment.

[Learn more about Private Residential architecture]

Urban Context 

Mixed-Use Architect: Mixed-use development can significantly change the face of localised urban design. A mixed-use development may integrate residential, commercial, and recreational uses into active and dynamic spaces, and can even promote walkable neighbourhoods free from car dependence. For instance, a well-designed mixed-use building can encourage revitalisation by bringing different sectors of the population together and fostering economic activity in that area. 

Architects have to take into consideration factors that include flow and movement of people, public transportation access, and green spaces in between to make the location more livable and attractive, like in the Housing 214. 

In addition, the scheme will need to overcome problems like noise pollution, traffic congestion, and its effects on infrastructure. The work needs foresight to connect with the big picture of urban planning, and developing the building to contribute something to the surrounding area. Beyond this, mixed-use architects take into consideration how their buildings and facilities fit within the greater cultural and historic contexts of a neighbourhood, town or city, mixing the new practical uses with the local vernacular. Public art, community spaces, and green planting can further contribute to such places within urban settings. 

Private Residential Architect: Private residential architects take on projects that are often more small-scale and personal, and their primary concern is to ensure a perfect environment is achieved for the client. While it is important that the residential architect takes account of the architectural surroundings and natural features found within the area where the house is situated, it is not usually necessary to imitate the general architectural style to produce a pastiche design. 

At Andrew Wallace Architects, we can design you a standout house, such as House 134, that is mindful of some specifics of the local street scene, such as scale, building line, amenity areas etc, but is designed more in line with your aspirations – be that the overall look and feel, or being designed around the needs and opportunities of contemporary living. 

This could be a house designed to make the most of a great view or garden space, creating outdoor areas that meld with their natural surroundings, or open-plan living to create a great sense of space internally. The focus here is on understanding how the owner would like to interact with the house and immediate surroundings, both internally and externally.

In these types of projects, the landscape frequently becomes an integral part of the design, so that it complements the architecture and enriches the living experience. Residential architects also consider privacy, noise control, and incorporation of natural light, all to enhance the overall well-being of the occupants.

Safety

Mixed-Use Architect: Safety in a mixed-use building is pretty complex. It requires the architects to design the building while having regard to fire safety, structural integrity, sustainability and accessibility, to name but a few, keeping in mind the varied users’ needs. For example, commercial areas might require fire escape routes that accommodate large crowds, while residential sections need separate secure entrances and exits, like in the Marks & Spencer project. 

Mixed-use architects also need to comply with extensive safety regulations, ensuring that all areas, from underground parking to rooftop terraces, are safe and accessible for the intended users. Other aspects involve emergency evacuation plans, electronic access, and security systems that separate areas of public/private space to keep the occupants safe. 

The large volume of users in these buildings demands a safety strategy that must be comprehensive. Architects should incorporate technological advancements, including surveillance cameras, sensors and automatic fire suppression within spaces in a mixed-use setting. Caring for the users’ safety with wide corridors, clearly navigable and signed circulation spaces and staircases ensures the user’s safety for the different purposes a building can serve. 

Private Residential Architect: Safety is equally important in a private residential project, but is generally a little simpler and geared towards keeping smaller numbers of people safe.

 As everyone is very familiar with living in houses and instinctively understands how a house functions, safety features do not need to be spelt out to the same extent. However, as children and babies can wander around these spaces unattended, extra thought needs to be applied to keeping this age group safe. 

All necessary elements such as childproofed staircases, means of escape and appropriate ventilation systems require careful consideration at the design stage. Safety measures in residential projects involve not just meeting building controls minimum requirements, but can also take into consideration the daily living needs of the specific family, such as a kitchen with an efficient ergonomic layout, accessible bathrooms, specifying non-slippery floor coverings and ample light in places where accidents could occur. 

Residential architects often incorporate smart home capabilities for added security and convenience. They may involve alarm systems or storm-resistant design and materials to ensure the house is future-proofed from drastic weather conditions, like in the House 146.

Creative Freedom

Mixed-Use Architect: While the mixed-use architect has to work within a strict framework, like planning and building regulations, client requirements, and budget constraints, there is still room for creativity. 

The challenge lies in designing solutions that balance functionality, efficiency, and aesthetic appeal. For instance, an architect may integrate green roofing terraces, energy-efficient systems, or striking façades that add character to the building within an urban environment. 

Creativeness for mixed-use projects usually lies in how different functions can be brought together while enhancing the building’s visual and functional harmony. It may include the design of multi-functional spaces, for example a lobby serving also as a communal gathering area (see the King’s Dock project), or the use of innovative materials and technologies for accomplishing sustainability parameters. 

Adding to the creative challenge is to develop schemes that will appeal to a large variety of users. The architect must balance functionality with distinctive design elements that leave a long-lasting impression and promote greater interaction and use. Other recent innovative concepts in mixed-use architecture include modular construction, adaptive reuse of existing structures, and biophilic design elements.

Private Residential Architect: In residential architecture, designers are often given more latitude for creativity. Many owners would want a design to be tailor-made according to their tastes and lifestyles, giving freedom for architects to play with form, structure, materials, and unique architectural features. Therefore, the residential architect will have multiple opportunities to design something unique, including by use of sustainable materials, integrating smart home technology, or seamlessly connecting the inside and outside, like in the House 164. 

This freedom extends to the interior design; bespoke fitted furniture, lighting schemes, and other artistic details personalise the house. The residential project can become the canvas for innovation and an outlet for the architect’s artistry. 

Architects in this field work with suppliers, manufacturers and craftspeople to create features that raise the aesthetic appeal of the home. The utilisation of advanced tools such as 3D CAD visualisations (see House 191) allows the client to see and explore the design to ascertain that the end product will be what the client requires to fulfil their aspirations.

Target Audience 

Mixed-Use Architect: A mixed-use architect generally works for property developers (both private and corporate) and other large organisations that aim to develop space for a variety of uses and users. These can involve various stakeholders, hence the need for an architect to balance priorities and expectations when delivering a cohesive and functional design. 

The audience for mixed-use projects is very broad; business owners, tenants, residents, visitors and the general public. Architects should, therefore, create spaces tending to this wide range of users by ensuring the building meets the needs of all its occupants while contributing to the community’s general well-being, like in the project Virginia House. 

In the absence of the client providing project related market research, when required architects dealing with mixed-use projects can commission market research on behalf of the client to identify the demographics of prospective users and so the design can be developed to incorporate their needs. In other cases, architects may consult closely with government authorities on matters regarding planning guidelines and environmental impact concerns, thus complying with greater urban planning directives.

Private Residential Architect: Most residential architects deal directly with private clients or families interested in building or remodelling their ideal home. They take care of the homeowners in all stages of the design and construction, from conception to completion. This close collaboration allows deep personalisation of the approach that guarantees the final result is in line with the clients’ needs and aspirations. 

Residential architects can find themselves building long lasting relationships with their clients because designing a home is highly personal experience for the clients, like the House 145. The target audience, the client, appreciates creativity, attention to detail and commitment to creating spaces that will become their home. 

At the other end of the private residential market, residential architects also may work with investors developing multiple high-end individual properties (like Housing 221) aimed at specific re-sale markets, working to ensure designs meet the expectations of potential buyers. 

Which Type of Architect Do You Require? 

The selection of the right architect is among the most important steps in transforming your vision into reality. The choice between a mixed-use and a private residential architect depends on the specific goals and requirements of your project. Each brings a specialized set of skills and expertise to the table, ensuring your project’s success. 

If you are planning a large-scale development that integrates various functions, such as residential, commercial, and recreational spaces, then a mixed-use architect is your best bet. They will be able to help you create a cohesive, efficient, and innovative design that benefits both individual users and the broader community. Such architects excel at managing the complexities. 

Hire Andrew Wallace Architects For Your Project 

At Andrew Wallace Architects, we specialise in both mixed-use and private residential projects. Whether you’re envisioning a dynamic space that blends work, living, and leisure, or seeking a bespoke design for your home, our team is here to help. With a passion for creating beautiful and functional spaces, our experienced architects are dedicated to bringing your vision to life.

With mixed-use projects, we excel in creating integrated spaces that balance rigorous functionality with aesthetic appeal, adding to the life of our towns and cities. We achieve our approach through collaboration and innovation so that every element of design performs its intended function while enhancing the overall experience for the users.

[Learn More About Mixed-Use Architecture]

Residentially, the focus is to create a home as unique as the individual residing in it. We engage our clients from initial concepts to final touches in designing a space that caters first and foremost to comfort, style, and practicality. The idea is to create a home that surpasses your expectations.

[Learn More About Private Residential Architecture]

Get in touch with us today to explore how we can tailor our services to suit your unique needs.

Contact Andrew Wallace Architects